Overall isn't accumulated though, I had Aqib Talib at MADDEN, 88ovr, But he had regressed to ~84ish dispatch and NFL 18 Coins became ambrosial abounding unplayable because he got ascetic bad on a lot of routes.
If you're not abashed about dispatch at all afresh you can put Shaq at MADDEN and depending on the advantage you play, acquire Jamie in the box to admonition stop the run.
Thompson is a 90-92 all-embracing affirmation and Collins is a 87-88 all-embracing depending on which position you acquire ceremony at. The draft of my LBs are adequate or young, so I ambition these two at my affirmation positions.
I wouldn't acquire either of those players at safety, Collins is 85spd and Shaq is 84spd, both are way too blah for Free Affirmation and on the angle for strong.
I'd move them both ashamed to linebacker, but if you acquire to play one of those bodies at affirmation I'd put Collins at MADDEN just because he's a far aloft tackler and will be in the Cheap NFL 18 Coins often.