Each year, the release of a new MLB The Show game sparks endless debates among fans and competitors alike: Who's the best player at every position? In MLB The Show 25, the competition is tighter than ever, with stacked lineups, new milestone cards, and lightning-fast updates from San Diego Studio.

After testing lineups, comparing stats, and analyzing the favorites among top MLB The Show 25 players, we've compiled the ultimate list of the best player at every position in Diamond Dynasty. Whether you're grinding Ranked Seasons, diving into Battle Royale, or trying to maximize your MLB 25 Stubs investments, these players represent the cream of the crop.

Catcher: Gary Sánchez

Kicking things off behind the plate, Gary Sánchez once again proves why he's a fan favorite in MLB The Show 25. His combination of elite power, quick bat speed, and a cannon of an arm makes him one of the most dangerous catchers in the game.

Sánchez can change a game with one swing, and his maxed-out power attributes make him a constant home run threat. Defensively, he's no liability either, his strong arm keeps baserunners honest. Whether you're using him in Ranked or grinding through programs, Sánchez is the perfect balance of offensive explosiveness and reliable defense.

First Base: Carlos Santana

At first base, we've got the new Carlos Santana card, and he's an absolute monster. What sets Santana apart from other first basemen is his smooth swing and positional flexibility, he can even catch in a pinch, making him incredibly valuable for roster building.

Santana's switch-hitting ability gives him favorable matchups no matter who's on the mound, and his discipline at the plate translates perfectly to consistent on-base performance. For players looking to stretch their MLB 25 Stubs while maximizing lineup versatility, Santana is one of the smartest pickups in the game right now.

Second Base: Lightning Jorge Polanco

The Lightning Series Jorge Polanco takes the crown at second base. This card embodies everything you could want from a middle infielder, contact, speed, and clutch hitting.

Polanco's balanced attributes make him lethal from both sides of the plate, and his swing feels incredibly smooth in-game. Defensively, he's quick enough to cover the gap and make tough plays look easy. He's a must-have for players who like to mix power with finesse, and his Lightning boost means he'll stay competitive even as new cards drop later in the season.

Third Base: 400 Home Run Club Chipper Jones

When it comes to third base, the legend himself Chipper Jones remains untouchable. His "400 Home Run Club" card is one of the most balanced and complete hitters in MLB The Show 25.

Chipper's switch-hitting prowess gives him a consistent edge against both lefties and righties. Combine that with elite vision, power, and discipline, and you've got one of the most feared bats in the game. He's also solid defensively, making him a reliable cornerstone for your infield.

If you've got the Stubs, Chipper Jones is absolutely worth the investment. Few players deliver the same combination of nostalgia and performance.

Shortstop: Milestone Elly De La Cruz

Next up is one of the most exciting new additions, the Milestone Elly De La Cruz card. This is one of those players that changes the energy of your entire lineup.

Elly brings a rare blend of speed, power, and fielding to the shortstop position. He can leg out singles, steal bases with ease, and launch moonshots when pitchers miss their spots. His defense and arm strength also make him elite on the field.

Many top MLB The Show 25 Players are already calling this Milestone card a game-changer. If you manage to unlock him early or snag him on the marketplace, don't hesitate, he's worth every MLB 25 Stub you spend.

Left Field: 99 Overall Ted Williams

In left field, it's no contest, 99 Overall Ted Williams stands alone. Every year, his card is a hitting clinic, and MLB The Show 25 is no exception.

Ted Williams boasts elite contact and power against both righties and lefties, along with one of the smoothest swings in the game. He's the definition of "pure hitter," capable of turning any pitch into an extra-base hit. While his defense is serviceable, you're putting him in the lineup for one reason, his bat.

If you can afford him, Williams will single-handedly raise your team's offensive ceiling.

Center Field: Byron Buxton

Few players in the game combine speed, defense, and raw athleticism like Byron Buxton. His new card in MLB The Show 25 solidifies him as one of the best all-around outfielders available.

Buxton covers more ground than almost any player, making him a defensive anchor in center. On offense, his swing has improved dramatically, and his power numbers are more than capable of turning him into a 5-tool superstar. He's perfect for players who prioritize defense and base-running, but don't want to sacrifice pop at the plate.

Right Field: 99 Overall Babe Ruth

When you talk about baseball legends, Babe Ruth needs no introduction, and his 99 Overall card in MLB The Show 25 is exactly what you'd expect: absolute dominance.

Ruth's hitting attributes are practically maxed out across the board, and his swing feels effortless. He can hit for both power and average, and his lefty bat adds crucial balance to any lineup. While his defense isn't elite, his offensive production more than makes up for it. Simply put, he's one of the best pure hitters in the entire game.

Starting Pitcher: John Donaldson

Every great lineup needs a reliable ace, and John Donaldson fits that role perfectly. With elite velocity, pinpoint control, and a devastating pitch mix, he's capable of shutting down any offense.

Donaldson's repertoire keeps hitters guessing, from high-heat fastballs to sweeping breaking balls, he can dominate from start to finish. He's also an ideal card for players looking to build around a balanced rotation with both stamina and strikeout potential.

Relief Pitcher: The Miz

Rounding out the roster, the Miz takes the top spot among relievers. He's the ultimate shutdown arm late in games, boasting filthy breaking pitches and clutch attributes that shine in high-pressure moments.

Whether you're protecting a one-run lead or trying to escape a jam, Miz delivers every time. Pair him with a strong rotation, and your pitching staff becomes nearly unbeatable.

Final Thoughts

With so many incredible options in MLB The Show 25, building your dream lineup has never been more exciting. These players represent the very best at their positions, a mix of legends, current stars, and breakout talents that define this year's meta.

If you're grinding for MLB 25 Stubs, investing in these cards is a smart move. They not only give you a competitive edge but also hold long-term value throughout the season.

Whether you're chasing trophies, climbing Ranked, or just looking to join the elite group of top MLB The Show 25 players, this lineup is the perfect place to start your journey to Diamond greatness.